Amplates. They look really nice. They delivered super-quickly and the badges themselves are great looking (even better looking than in this slightly blurry picture from my web camera.) Joe at Amplates made up vector art from my Photoshop file and made the lines even cleaner and better-er. I couldn't be happier with the work or the price.
Yes, this is the goofiest picture of me possible.
UPDATE: Ethan's comment: "We don't need no stinkin' badges." ;-)